A defect nobody could see
Quoted
~$48,000
Work on the back of the house, plus $1,500 for engineering
Defect cited
A horizontal crack
What I observed
- The interior basement wall was finished with drywall, so the foundation behind it was not visible.
- The exterior wall showed no vertical cracking, and there was no way to observe a horizontal crack from outside.
- The drywall showed no bowing and no deflection.
- Soil had settled around the perimeter of the house.
- A small amount of water had entered on the opposite side of the house during one major rainstorm.
The teachable point
The quote named a defect that could not be observed from either side of the wall — and the inward deflection that normally accompanies that defect was absent. That does not prove the crack is not there. It means the homeowner had no way of knowing, and had two specific questions available: show me the crack, and how was it assessed through a finished wall?
The findings I could document — settled soil around the perimeter, and one instance of water on the far side of the house — point somewhere quite different from the back wall, and to remedies in a different price class.